Avoiding Independent Contractor Rules in Canadian Business 2024

There are distinct differences between independent contractors and employees, with the former having different legal entitlements. Employees have an exclusive working relationship with their employer and are governed under the Employment Act, whereas an independent contractor are not subject to the same statute and have different employment law protections. In Canada, companies may opt for an independent contractor as they are not responsible for their taxes, which are separate from the company’s business tax. Nonetheless, there are inherent risks with this type of employment. Fortunately, there are ways to mitigate these risks.



What are the Risks Associated with Hiring an Independent Contractor for Companies?

Hiring independent contractors instead of employees can provide various advantages to companies. However, this type of employment arrangement also exposes companies to financial risks, such as fines and penalties. Some companies may classify their employees as independent contractors to avoid certain business taxes or to shift the responsibility of paying independent contractor taxes to the contractors themselves.

In some cases, employees may not even be aware that they are not on a permanent contract basis and are instead hired as independent contractors. They may only find out about their status when their contract is terminated, and they are not entitled to any insurance benefits.

How to mitigate these risks?

Control

To avoid any issues with the PSB, you should take charge of your workers. Make sure to specify in their contracts whether they will work under your direct supervision, as this will create a clear distinction.

Bringing their own tools

If a company requires workers to provide their own equipment and software, they are likely hiring independent contractors rather than employees. Large-scale companies typically provide their own equipment, so if you are expected to bring your own tools, it’s likely that you are being hired on an independent contractual basis.

Risk of loss

If delivering a service could result in a financial risk, you are likely to be classified as an independent contractor, not an employee. Employees should not be expected to incur expenses while providing a service to the company, such as using their own car or phone. These expenses are reimbursed by the employer and help distinguish independent contractors from permanent employees.

Ability to earn a profit.

If there is an opportunity to earn a profit in addition to your salary, make sure to include this in your employer-employee contract. Clearly state that if certain milestones or targets are met, you are entitled to a reward or share in the profit.

Financial independence

If you work for more than one company and have multiple clients, you are considered an independent contractor. Make sure to clarify this arrangement to create a clear distinction and mitigate any risks.



Is the company responsible for providing health insurance?

In Canada, there has been a growing trend of legal cases where plaintiffs argue that they were misclassified as independent contractors instead of employees. If a court finds in favor of the plaintiff, the company could be held responsible for contributing towards their health insurance and pension plan, as well as potential damages.

What are the risks of working as an independent contractor for businesses?

In Canada, authorities are vigilant about companies that may be misclassifying workers as independent contractors and may impose severe fines and sanctions. If caught, a company may be required to make backdated payments, pay interest on those payments, damages, and fines, and may even face public scrutiny. Canada has strict rules against misclassification, and the burden of proof lies with the employer to prove that a worker is an independent contractor, rather than with the employee.

Is it necessary to create a contract when hiring an independent contractor?

Yes, it is essential to have a clear contract that specifies whether the worker is being hired as an independent contractor, who is responsible for paying independent contractor taxes, or as an employee, for whom the company is responsible for paying business taxes. Failing to make this distinction can lead to confusion and potential legal issues. It is advisable to clarify this distinction upfront to avoid any misunderstandings. In case of any legal issues, if the company is unable to prove the worker’s status, it can face significant losses.



Obtaining a Master Business License in Ontario

Are you eager to start your own business venture in Canada? Do you have an innovative business concept in mind? If so, it’s worth considering applying for a master’s Business License. This license is essential for anyone looking to launch a business in Ontario, and it ensures that your company is established efficiently and effectively.

With a master’s Business License, you’ll be able to legally use your chosen business name and enjoy additional benefits as a business owner. Whether you’re planning to set up a sole proprietorship, general partnership, or trade name, this license can help you register your business under the Business Names Act. Keep in mind that any company you see advertised on TV, billboards, or online has likely obtained this master Business License before launching their business.

What a master business license is?

Essentially, it’s a document that contains important details about your business such as its name, address, business number, and a brief overview of what it does. Additionally, it specifies the type of company you have – whether it’s a sole trader, sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability, or tradename.

In conclusion,

Independent contractors are a popular choice for small businesses in Canada due to favorable tax benefits. However, there are potential risks involved if employers misclassify their workers as independent contractors solely to reduce costs and obligations. It’s important to ensure that the worker’s status is properly determined to avoid any legal and financial consequences.

Share This Blog

A man is sitting in front of a computer with a graph on it.
April 15, 2025
Uncover strategies to navigate financial challenges in Ontario's evolving economy with expert advice.
A woman is sitting on a couch looking at her finances.
February 18, 2025
Explore personalized tax planning tips for Ontario residents, ensuring you make informed decisions this tax season
A person is sitting at a desk with a calculator and a wooden block with the word tax on it.
January 16, 2025
Get ready for tax season with our comprehensive checklist. A practical resource to help individuals and businesses stay organized.
A man and a woman are sitting on the floor looking at a clipboard.
January 4, 2025
Understand how to integrate charitable giving into estate plans. Discover the benefits of fulfilling philanthropic goals and optimizing tax liabilities.
A woman is sitting at a desk using a laptop computer.
December 18, 2024
Explore the tax considerations of remote work in Canada. Learn about potential deductions, compliance issues, and optimizing tax outcomes.
A man is sitting at a desk with a laptop and a cell phone.
December 4, 2024
Plan for success in 2025 with our year-end financial review guide. Identify areas for improvement and strategize for the future.
A man in a suit and glasses is sitting at a table writing on a piece of paper.
November 12, 2024
Uncover retirement planning essentials tailored for business owners. Explore IRA options and strategies to secure your financial future.
A road going through a snowy forest with mountains in the background
By KimiB May 31, 2024
If you happen to reside in the northern regions of Canada, we have some great news for you! The travel deductions available for northern residents have been expanded, allowing more individuals to claim their expenses for trips to and from these areas on their 2021 tax returns. Curious to know more about these updated deductions? [...]
A man is sitting at a desk using a calculator and writing in a notebook.
By KimiB May 29, 2024
Understanding your financial needs and sufficiency is crucial when it comes to financial planning. One key aspect of this is getting an accurate estimate of how much income tax, marginal tax, you might owe each year, as this will help you better understand how much of your income you can save, spend, and invest. If [...]
A man is sitting at a desk holding a cup of coffee and writing in a notebook.
By KimiB May 28, 2024
Did you know that while capital gains are taxable, capital losses can be deducted? And with certain conditions, you can even carry those losses forward to offset taxes on future capital gains. Let's break down what qualifies as a capital loss and explore how you can take advantage of it, step by step. Bookkeeping in [...]